Operation Sindoor and the Ratchet Effect: Why the South Asian Nuclear Flashpoint Is Structurally More Dangerous Than Before
Keywords:
Operation Sindoor · India-Pakistan conflict · Hindutva · Kashmir · nuclear escalation · Indus Waters Treaty · ratchet effect · full-spectrum deterrenceAbstract
This paper examines Operation Sindoor as the product of four interlocking structural conditions: the contested origins of the Pahalgam attack; Hindutva ideology’s foreclosure of diplomatic resolution; National Security Adviser (NSA) Ajit Doval’s ‘defensive offence’ doctrine; and India’s accelerating isolation in a multipolar order in which Pakistan has emerged as an indispensable regional mediator. Utilising open-source intelligence, official government statements and communiqués, think-tank assessments from the Stimson Center, Harvard's Belfer Center, and RSIS Singapore, peer-reviewed scholarship on Hindutva nationalism, and reporting from Foreign Affairs, The Diplomat, The Intercept, and The Jerusalem Post, the analysis finds that Operation Sindoor failed to achieve its strategic objectives. Elizabeth Threlkeld (Stimson Center/Foreign Affairs, 2026) identifies a ‘ratchet effect’: each confrontation resets the escalation baseline upward with no improvement in crisis-management architecture, making the next crisis structurally more dangerous. The paper contributes the ratchet effect framework to Pakistani strategic studies, analyses deterrence postures symmetrically, and identifies concrete policy steps to convert Pakistan’s current diplomatic standing into durable crisis-management architecture.
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 By submitting an article to the editor, the author (s) will automatically grant editors the rights to edit and post the content of the articles on the official website of the Sadiq Journal of Pakistan Studies (SJPS) if accepted. Author (s) retain the copyrights and will grant SJPS the non-exclusive rights of first publication of manuscript electronically and in print form and to identify SJPS as the original publisher under creative commons License. It will allow others to share the content with explicit indication of the authorship and its initial publication in SJPS. Under these licensing terms, the author (s) confirm that all the content of the published manuscript will be distributed in the public domain and other researchers may use it exclusively for the non-profit scientific purpose (s) with the obligatory acknowledgement of authorship. Author (s) reserves unconditional rights to copy and reproduce the published work for teaching, use it in other research and redistribute, share or place the copy of the article to any other medium or format, even commercially only if SJPS is explicitly acknowledged as the original publisher. However, author (s) cannot apply any legal or technological measures that legally restrict others from doing anything that is already permitted under the license terms.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
All the articles editorially accepted for publication by the Sadiq Journal of Pakistan Studies (SJPS) are licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0). Submitting a manuscript to SJPS, the author has to certify that he/ she is authorized by other contributors (s) and co-author (s) to enter the publication process.
He/ She shall assure on behalf of all author (s) that:
- The manuscript is original, it has not been published in any other journal before, is not under consideration for any other journal and does not violate any existing copyrights or any other rights of a third party.
- I/we have full authority to enter into this agreement for granting the rights to SJPS as sole author (s) of the article without breaching any other obligation.
- The manuscript does not contain any unlawful and libelous content or anything that would breach the agreement (s) of confidence, commitment, and secrecy.
- I/we certify that due care has been taken to ensure the reliability of the article. All purported statements and information are facts to the best of my/our knowledge and the currently accepted standards of scientific knowledge. Therefore, any of the proposed methods or instructions will not, if followed accurately, cause any damage or loss to the user (s).
